From Spot to Contract: How Mid-Sized Brokers Can Win Against the Majors

If you run a mid-sized brokerage, you already know the problem: contracted lanes are locked up by the largest players. CH Robinson, XPO, TQL—they dominate the RFPs, the multi-year agreements, the “set it and forget it” freight. For everyone else, it feels like the only option is fighting over the scraps of the spot market.

One broker on r/FreightBrokers put it bluntly: ‘There is this secret society of a “Contract Freight” market’ — a reminder that many in the trenches believe contract lanes are often quietly reserved for insiders.

Here’s the truth: you’re not going to beat the large national brokerages everywhere. They have scale, pricing leverage, and massive carrier networks. But you can beat them somewhere. And once you do, you can turn that wedge into a contracted lane that sticks.

This blog shows you how.

Why Contract Freight Feels Locked Up

Contract freight is where shippers find stability. They want predictable rates, guaranteed coverage, and less firefighting. The majors deliver that by sheer size: hundreds of thousands of carriers, deep data sets, and the ability to spread risk across massive networks.

For a mid-sized brokerage, competing head-to-head on every lane is suicide. You can’t undercut their rates forever, and you can’t match their coverage. The result? You burn sales cycles chasing RFPs you’ll never win.

As

: ‘Contract rates remain a snapshot of the market when the contract was enacted’ — which helps explain why some contracted lanes still outperform spot even in changing market cycles.

The Case for Niches

Where the large players struggle, you thrive. Complex, messy, or specialized freight is your advantage.

• Multi-stop or regional lanes the nationals don’t prioritize. Perishable and food products often do milk-run style shipments.

• Specialized equipment like reefer, hazmat, or flatbed.

• Perishable or high-service cargo where relationships and agility matter more than scale. Delivering cargo to job sites tends to be a good place to start. The big guys stay away from these types of high-touch deliveries.

Think like a sniper, not a shotgun. Own a geography. Own a commodity. Own the lanes where your carrier base already outperforms the majors. That’s where you have leverage.

Turning Spot Wins Into Contracted Lanes

FreightWaves recently published a guide on how to blend spot, contract, and direct freight strategically — exactly the kind of ‘middle path’ playbook mid-sized brokers need.

Winning spot freight isn’t just about margin—it’s your audition for contract business. Treat every spot load as a live sales pitch.

• Over-deliver on execution. Be the fastest to quote, the most transparent in communication, and the cleanest on paperwork.

• Document performance. Track OTIF%, claims, and cost variance. Don’t just do a good job—prove it.

• Bring the data back to the shipper. Show them you’ve already created contract-like consistency.

When you frame it right, the question isn’t “Should we give you a contract?” It’s “Why wouldn’t we, since you’re already outperforming our incumbents?”

Marketing Strategies That Convert Spot to Contract

Here’s where most brokers stop—and where you can pull ahead. Layer in marketing tactics that feel foreign to freight, but irresistible to shippers.

• Micro-Case Studies: After 5 successful spot loads, send a 1-page branded report showing your performance metrics. Make it impossible for procurement to ignore.

• Lane Ownership Pitch: Don’t ask for all their freight. Ask for the Dallas–Chicago lane you’ve nailed 10 times in a row. Niche wins scale faster.

• Branded Load Reports: After each shipment, send a recap with transit time, cost, and exception handling. Shippers love visibility—even more when it’s proactive.

• Trojan Horse Strategy: Start on the sidelines. Nail the “hard to cover” lanes no one else wants. Once you prove reliability, push for share of core freight.

• Social Proof Marketing: Share performance benchmarks or carrier testimonials on LinkedIn/email campaigns. In an industry full of cold calls, proactive storytelling stands out.

These aren’t gimmicks—they’re weapons. They position you as more than a broker. They make you look like a partner.

Before vs After Metrics

The proof is in the numbers. Track how your brokerage evolves when you flip spot into contract:

• Conversion rate: Spot lanes won → contracted lanes awarded.

• Share of wallet: Percent of total freight spend you capture from each shipper.

• Margin stability: Contract mix cushions against market volatility.

• Sales efficiency: Shorter sales cycles when data and proof replace persuasion.

Pitfalls to Avoid

Contract conversion isn’t about chasing everything. Watch out for:

• Spreading too thin across lanes you can’t service consistently.

• Over-promising coverage you don’t have.

• Forgetting that contracts are won on trust as much as rate.

The goal isn’t just to “win” freight. It’s to win freight you can keep.

FAQ

Why do large brokerages dominate contracted freight?
Because scale lets them offer stability and coverage across thousands of lanes.

Can small/mid brokerages realistically win contracts?
Yes—but only by owning niches and proving performance on spot freight first. In a thread on r/supplychain, users debated the merits of one-year vs multi-year contracts — many preferring one-year deals because they allow renegotiation as markets shift.

What’s the best way to identify winnable lanes?
Start with lanes where your carrier base is strong, or where shippers complain about poor service from incumbents.

How do you prove to shippers you deserve a contract?
Track and share OTIF%, claims ratios, and cost stability on spot freight. Turn data into a sales tool.

What KPIs matter most in conversion?
Spot-to-contract conversion rate, margin stability, and share of wallet with each shipper.

Next Steps

Contract freight may feel locked up by the majors, but mid-sized brokerages have a path in: niches, performance, and growth-hacker marketing. The formula is simple—win on the edges, document success, and turn those edges into contracted lanes.

Book a 30-minute consult to see how Rilix helps mid-sized brokerages flip spot wins into lasting contracts.

Book Demo